Construct Runtime v2 (#1378)

Moved from paritytech/substrate#14788

----

Fixes #232

This PR introduces outer-macro approach for `construct_runtime` as
discussed in the linked issue. It looks like the following:
```rust
#[frame_support::runtime]
mod runtime {
	#[runtime::runtime]
        #[runtime::derive(
		RuntimeCall,
		RuntimeEvent,
		RuntimeError,
		RuntimeOrigin,
		RuntimeFreezeReason,
		RuntimeHoldReason,
		RuntimeSlashReason,
		RuntimeLockId,
                RuntimeTask,
	)]
	pub struct Runtime;

	#[runtime::pallet_index(0)]
	pub type System = frame_system;

	#[runtime::pallet_index(1)]
	pub type Timestamp = pallet_timestamp;

	#[runtime::pallet_index(2)]
	pub type Aura = pallet_aura;

	#[runtime::pallet_index(3)]
	pub type Grandpa = pallet_grandpa;

	#[runtime::pallet_index(4)]
	pub type Balances = pallet_balances;

	#[runtime::pallet_index(5)]
	pub type TransactionPayment = pallet_transaction_payment;

	#[runtime::pallet_index(6)]
	pub type Sudo = pallet_sudo;

	// Include the custom logic from the pallet-template in the runtime.
	#[runtime::pallet_index(7)]
	pub type TemplateModule = pallet_template;
}
```

## Features
- `#[runtime::runtime]` attached to a struct defines the main runtime
- `#[runtime::derive]` attached to this struct defines the types
generated by runtime
- `#[runtime::pallet_index]` must be attached to a pallet to define its
index
- `#[runtime::disable_call]` can be optionally attached to a pallet to
disable its calls
- `#[runtime::disable_unsigned]` can be optionally attached to a pallet
to disable unsigned calls
- A pallet instance can be defined as `TemplateModule:
pallet_template<Instance>`
- An optional attribute can be defined as
`#[frame_support::runtime(legacy_ordering)]` to ensure that the order of
hooks is same as the order of pallets (and not based on the
pallet_index). This is to support legacy runtimes and should be avoided
for new ones.

## Todo
- [x] Update the latest syntax in kitchensink and tests
- [x] Update UI tests
- [x] Docs

## Extension
- Abstract away the Executive similar to
paritytech/substrate#14742
- Optionally avoid the need to specify all runtime types (TBD)

---------

Co-authored-by: Francisco Aguirre <[email protected]>
Co-authored-by: Nikhil Gupta <>

prdoc/pr_1378.prdoc

@@ -0,0 +1,27 @@
+title: Construct Runtime V2 - An outer macro approach to define the runtime
+
+doc:
+  - audience: Runtime Dev
+    description: |
+      Introduces `#[frame_support::runtime]` that can be attached to a mod to define a runtime. The items 
+      in this mod can be attached to the following attributes to define the key components of the runtime.
+      1. `#[runtime::runtime]` attached to a struct defines the main runtime
+      2. `#[runtime::derive]` attached to the runtime struct defines the types generated by the runtime
+      3. `#[runtime::pallet_index]` must be attached to a pallet to define its index
+      4. `#[runtime::disable_call]` can be optionally attached to a pallet to disable its calls
+      5. `#[runtime::disable_unsigned]` can be optionally attached to a pallet to disable unsigned calls
+      6. A pallet instance can be defined as `TemplateModule: pallet_template<Instance>`
+      An optional attribute can be defined as `#[frame_support::runtime(legacy_ordering)]` to ensure that 
+      the order of hooks is same as the order of pallets (and not based on the pallet_index). This is to support 
+      legacy runtimes and should be avoided for new ones.
+
+migrations:
+  db: []
+
+  runtime: []
+
+crates:
+  - name: frame-support
+  - name: frame-support-procedural
+
+host_functions: []

substrate/bin/node/runtime/Cargo.toml

@@ -58,7 +58,7 @@ sp-io = { path = "../../../primitives/io", default-features = false }
 frame-executive = { path = "../../../frame/executive", default-features = false }
 frame-benchmarking = { path = "../../../frame/benchmarking", default-features = false }
 frame-benchmarking-pallet-pov = { path = "../../../frame/benchmarking/pov", default-features = false }
-frame-support = { path = "../../../frame/support", default-features = false, features = ["tuples-96"] }
+frame-support = { path = "../../../frame/support", default-features = false, features = ["experimental", "tuples-96"] }
 frame-system = { path = "../../../frame/system", default-features = false }
 frame-system-benchmarking = { path = "../../../frame/system/benchmarking", default-features = false, optional = true }
 frame-election-provider-support = { path = "../../../frame/election-provider-support", default-features = false }

substrate/bin/node/runtime/src/lib.rs

@@ -28,7 +28,7 @@ use frame_election_provider_support::{
 	onchain, BalancingConfig, ElectionDataProvider, SequentialPhragmen, VoteWeight,
 };
 use frame_support::{
-	construct_runtime, derive_impl,
+	derive_impl,
 	dispatch::DispatchClass,
 	dynamic_params::{dynamic_pallet_params, dynamic_params},
 	genesis_builder_helper::{build_config, create_default_config},
@@ -2196,92 +2196,260 @@ impl pallet_parameters::Config for Runtime {
 	type WeightInfo = ();
 }
 
-construct_runtime!(
-	pub enum Runtime {
-		System: frame_system,
-		Utility: pallet_utility,
-		Babe: pallet_babe,
-		Timestamp: pallet_timestamp,
-		// Authorship must be before session in order to note author in the correct session and era
-		// for im-online and staking.
-		Authorship: pallet_authorship,
-		Indices: pallet_indices,
-		Balances: pallet_balances,
-		TransactionPayment: pallet_transaction_payment,
-		AssetTxPayment: pallet_asset_tx_payment,
-		AssetConversionTxPayment: pallet_asset_conversion_tx_payment,
-		ElectionProviderMultiPhase: pallet_election_provider_multi_phase,
-		Staking: pallet_staking,
-		Session: pallet_session,
-		Democracy: pallet_democracy,
-		Council: pallet_collective::<Instance1>,
-		TechnicalCommittee: pallet_collective::<Instance2>,
-		Elections: pallet_elections_phragmen,
-		TechnicalMembership: pallet_membership::<Instance1>,
-		Grandpa: pallet_grandpa,
-		Treasury: pallet_treasury,
-		AssetRate: pallet_asset_rate,
-		Contracts: pallet_contracts,
-		Sudo: pallet_sudo,
-		ImOnline: pallet_im_online,
-		AuthorityDiscovery: pallet_authority_discovery,
-		Offences: pallet_offences,
-		Historical: pallet_session_historical,
-		RandomnessCollectiveFlip: pallet_insecure_randomness_collective_flip,
-		Identity: pallet_identity,
-		Society: pallet_society,
-		Recovery: pallet_recovery,
-		Vesting: pallet_vesting,
-		Scheduler: pallet_scheduler,
-		Glutton: pallet_glutton,
-		Preimage: pallet_preimage,
-		Proxy: pallet_proxy,
-		Multisig: pallet_multisig,
-		Bounties: pallet_bounties,
-		Tips: pallet_tips,
-		Assets: pallet_assets::<Instance1>,
-		PoolAssets: pallet_assets::<Instance2>,
-		Beefy: pallet_beefy,
-		// MMR leaf construction must be after session in order to have a leaf's next_auth_set
-		// refer to block<N>. See issue polkadot-fellows/runtimes#160 for details.
-		Mmr: pallet_mmr,
-		MmrLeaf: pallet_beefy_mmr,
-		Lottery: pallet_lottery,
-		Nis: pallet_nis,
-		Uniques: pallet_uniques,
-		Nfts: pallet_nfts,
-		NftFractionalization: pallet_nft_fractionalization,
-		Salary: pallet_salary,
-		CoreFellowship: pallet_core_fellowship,
-		TransactionStorage: pallet_transaction_storage,
-		VoterList: pallet_bags_list::<Instance1>,
-		StateTrieMigration: pallet_state_trie_migration,
-		ChildBounties: pallet_child_bounties,
-		Referenda: pallet_referenda,
-		Remark: pallet_remark,
-		RootTesting: pallet_root_testing,
-		ConvictionVoting: pallet_conviction_voting,
-		Whitelist: pallet_whitelist,
-		AllianceMotion: pallet_collective::<Instance3>,
-		Alliance: pallet_alliance,
-		NominationPools: pallet_nomination_pools,
-		RankedPolls: pallet_referenda::<Instance2>,
-		RankedCollective: pallet_ranked_collective,
-		AssetConversion: pallet_asset_conversion,
-		FastUnstake: pallet_fast_unstake,
-		MessageQueue: pallet_message_queue,
-		Pov: frame_benchmarking_pallet_pov,
-		TxPause: pallet_tx_pause,
-		SafeMode: pallet_safe_mode,
-		Statement: pallet_statement,
-		MultiBlockMigrations: pallet_migrations,
-		Broker: pallet_broker,
-		TasksExample: pallet_example_tasks,
-		Mixnet: pallet_mixnet,
-		Parameters: pallet_parameters,
-		SkipFeelessPayment: pallet_skip_feeless_payment,
-	}
-);
+#[frame_support::runtime]
+mod runtime {
+	#[runtime::runtime]
+	#[runtime::derive(
+		RuntimeCall,
+		RuntimeEvent,
+		RuntimeError,
+		RuntimeOrigin,
+		RuntimeFreezeReason,
+		RuntimeHoldReason,
+		RuntimeSlashReason,
+		RuntimeLockId,
+		RuntimeTask
+	)]
+	pub struct Runtime;
+
+	#[runtime::pallet_index(0)]
+	pub type System = frame_system;
+
+	#[runtime::pallet_index(1)]
+	pub type Utility = pallet_utility;
+
+	#[runtime::pallet_index(2)]
+	pub type Babe = pallet_babe;
+
+	#[runtime::pallet_index(3)]
+	pub type Timestamp = pallet_timestamp;
+
+	// Authorship must be before session in order to note author in the correct session and era
+	// for im-online and staking.
+	#[runtime::pallet_index(4)]
+	pub type Authorship = pallet_authorship;
+
+	#[runtime::pallet_index(5)]
+	pub type Indices = pallet_indices;
+
+	#[runtime::pallet_index(6)]
+	pub type Balances = pallet_balances;
+
+	#[runtime::pallet_index(7)]
+	pub type TransactionPayment = pallet_transaction_payment;
+
+	#[runtime::pallet_index(8)]
+	pub type AssetTxPayment = pallet_asset_tx_payment;
+
+	#[runtime::pallet_index(9)]
+	pub type AssetConversionTxPayment = pallet_asset_conversion_tx_payment;
+
+	#[runtime::pallet_index(10)]
+	pub type ElectionProviderMultiPhase = pallet_election_provider_multi_phase;
+
+	#[runtime::pallet_index(11)]
+	pub type Staking = pallet_staking;
+
+	#[runtime::pallet_index(12)]
+	pub type Session = pallet_session;
+
+	#[runtime::pallet_index(13)]
+	pub type Democracy = pallet_democracy;
+
+	#[runtime::pallet_index(14)]
+	pub type Council = pallet_collective<Instance1>;
+
+	#[runtime::pallet_index(15)]
+	pub type TechnicalCommittee = pallet_collective<Instance2>;
+
+	#[runtime::pallet_index(16)]
+	pub type Elections = pallet_elections_phragmen;
+
+	#[runtime::pallet_index(17)]
+	pub type TechnicalMembership = pallet_membership<Instance1>;
+
+	#[runtime::pallet_index(18)]
+	pub type Grandpa = pallet_grandpa;
+
+	#[runtime::pallet_index(19)]
+	pub type Treasury = pallet_treasury;
+
+	#[runtime::pallet_index(20)]
+	pub type AssetRate = pallet_asset_rate;
+
+	#[runtime::pallet_index(21)]
+	pub type Contracts = pallet_contracts;
+
+	#[runtime::pallet_index(22)]
+	pub type Sudo = pallet_sudo;
+
+	#[runtime::pallet_index(23)]
+	pub type ImOnline = pallet_im_online;
+
+	#[runtime::pallet_index(24)]
+	pub type AuthorityDiscovery = pallet_authority_discovery;
+
+	#[runtime::pallet_index(25)]
+	pub type Offences = pallet_offences;
+
+	#[runtime::pallet_index(26)]
+	pub type Historical = pallet_session_historical;
+
+	#[runtime::pallet_index(27)]
+	pub type RandomnessCollectiveFlip = pallet_insecure_randomness_collective_flip;
+
+	#[runtime::pallet_index(28)]
+	pub type Identity = pallet_identity;
+
+	#[runtime::pallet_index(29)]
+	pub type Society = pallet_society;
+
+	#[runtime::pallet_index(30)]
+	pub type Recovery = pallet_recovery;
+
+	#[runtime::pallet_index(31)]
+	pub type Vesting = pallet_vesting;
+
+	#[runtime::pallet_index(32)]
+	pub type Scheduler = pallet_scheduler;
+
+	#[runtime::pallet_index(33)]
+	pub type Glutton = pallet_glutton;
+
+	#[runtime::pallet_index(34)]
+	pub type Preimage = pallet_preimage;
+
+	#[runtime::pallet_index(35)]
+	pub type Proxy = pallet_proxy;
+
+	#[runtime::pallet_index(36)]
+	pub type Multisig = pallet_multisig;
+
+	#[runtime::pallet_index(37)]
+	pub type Bounties = pallet_bounties;
+
+	#[runtime::pallet_index(38)]
+	pub type Tips = pallet_tips;
+
+	#[runtime::pallet_index(39)]
+	pub type Assets = pallet_assets<Instance1>;
+
+	#[runtime::pallet_index(40)]
+	pub type PoolAssets = pallet_assets<Instance2>;
+
+	#[runtime::pallet_index(41)]
+	pub type Beefy = pallet_beefy;
+
+	// MMR leaf construction must be after session in order to have a leaf's next_auth_set
+	// refer to block<N>. See issue polkadot-fellows/runtimes#160 for details.
+	#[runtime::pallet_index(42)]
+	pub type Mmr = pallet_mmr;
+
+	#[runtime::pallet_index(43)]
+	pub type MmrLeaf = pallet_beefy_mmr;
+
+	#[runtime::pallet_index(44)]
+	pub type Lottery = pallet_lottery;
+
+	#[runtime::pallet_index(45)]
+	pub type Nis = pallet_nis;
+
+	#[runtime::pallet_index(46)]
+	pub type Uniques = pallet_uniques;
+
+	#[runtime::pallet_index(47)]
+	pub type Nfts = pallet_nfts;
+
+	#[runtime::pallet_index(48)]
+	pub type NftFractionalization = pallet_nft_fractionalization;
+
+	#[runtime::pallet_index(49)]
+	pub type Salary = pallet_salary;
+
+	#[runtime::pallet_index(50)]
+	pub type CoreFellowship = pallet_core_fellowship;
+
+	#[runtime::pallet_index(51)]
+	pub type TransactionStorage = pallet_transaction_storage;
+
+	#[runtime::pallet_index(52)]
+	pub type VoterList = pallet_bags_list<Instance1>;
+
+	#[runtime::pallet_index(53)]
+	pub type StateTrieMigration = pallet_state_trie_migration;
+
+	#[runtime::pallet_index(54)]
+	pub type ChildBounties = pallet_child_bounties;
+
+	#[runtime::pallet_index(55)]
+	pub type Referenda = pallet_referenda;
+
+	#[runtime::pallet_index(56)]
+	pub type Remark = pallet_remark;
+
+	#[runtime::pallet_index(57)]
+	pub type RootTesting = pallet_root_testing;
+
+	#[runtime::pallet_index(58)]
+	pub type ConvictionVoting = pallet_conviction_voting;
+
+	#[runtime::pallet_index(59)]
+	pub type Whitelist = pallet_whitelist;
+
+	#[runtime::pallet_index(60)]
+	pub type AllianceMotion = pallet_collective<Instance3>;
+
+	#[runtime::pallet_index(61)]
+	pub type Alliance = pallet_alliance;
+
+	#[runtime::pallet_index(62)]
+	pub type NominationPools = pallet_nomination_pools;
+
+	#[runtime::pallet_index(63)]
+	pub type RankedPolls = pallet_referenda<Instance2>;
+
+	#[runtime::pallet_index(64)]
+	pub type RankedCollective = pallet_ranked_collective;
+
+	#[runtime::pallet_index(65)]
+	pub type AssetConversion = pallet_asset_conversion;
+
+	#[runtime::pallet_index(66)]
+	pub type FastUnstake = pallet_fast_unstake;
+
+	#[runtime::pallet_index(67)]
+	pub type MessageQueue = pallet_message_queue;
+
+	#[runtime::pallet_index(68)]
+	pub type Pov = frame_benchmarking_pallet_pov;
+
+	#[runtime::pallet_index(69)]
+	pub type TxPause = pallet_tx_pause;
+
+	#[runtime::pallet_index(70)]
+	pub type SafeMode = pallet_safe_mode;
+
+	#[runtime::pallet_index(71)]
+	pub type Statement = pallet_statement;
+
+	#[runtime::pallet_index(72)]
+	pub type MultiBlockMigrations = pallet_migrations;
+
+	#[runtime::pallet_index(73)]
+	pub type Broker = pallet_broker;
+
+	#[runtime::pallet_index(74)]
+	pub type TasksExample = pallet_example_tasks;
+
+	#[runtime::pallet_index(75)]
+	pub type Mixnet = pallet_mixnet;
+
+	#[runtime::pallet_index(76)]
+	pub type Parameters = pallet_parameters;
+
+	#[runtime::pallet_index(77)]
+	pub type SkipFeelessPayment = pallet_skip_feeless_payment;
+}
 
 /// The address format for describing accounts.
 pub type Address = sp_runtime::MultiAddress<AccountId, AccountIndex>;